We Are Closed



Dear valuable customers and friends, 
In an effort to protect our community and our staff since health and well-being have become the first priority at the moment, after serious consideration, The Pie Store will be closed effective March 17th will reopen as soon as is deemed safe. 
follow us on Instagram @thepiestore and Facebook: The Pie Store for more updates 
Thank you for your support and understanding. Together, we shall overcome this adversity to become but a stronger community physically and spiritually.”

njm-logoWe Americans may feel we invented the deliciously flaky pies that will adorn our Thanksgiving tables, but like the Pilgrims themselves, the concept of sweets or savories wrapped in dough actually came from across the Pond. Thanks to the Pie Store in Montclair, all you have to do to serve one of these heritage creations is warm it up in the oven. Read More

header-foodHands down the most fabulous key lime pie anywhere, and I mean anywhere, can be bought at The Pie Store in Montclair. I’ve tasted key lime pie in Key West, Florida and had many versions from many places in my life, but none can compete with this pie. Read more
yelp-5-star2-193x123Came in for banoffee pie after searching on yelp and left with 2 bag filled with goodies very nice owners and people working there
To top it off, it’s a heaven for anyone looking for goodies from the UK – dairy milk chocolates, sodas, h&p sauces, curries, beans, golden syrup…so many random things that you didn’t you could find ! What a find ! Read More